Login

Lost your password?

Sign Up

Register

Login

Login

Lost your password?

Register

Thursday, May 19, 2022
  • Home
  • Banking
  • Industry & Trade
  • Investing
  • Money Deals
  • Regional Markets
  • Tech & Biz
  • Countries
  • Opinion

Africa's
Investment
Gateway

The Exchange
  • Login
  • Register
Subscribe
This Month's Edition
Previous Editions
  • Home
  • Banking
  • Industry & Trade
  • Investing
  • Money Deals
  • Regional Markets
  • Tech & Biz
  • Countries
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
The Exchange
  • Home
  • Banking
  • Industry & Trade
  • Investing
  • Money Deals
  • Regional Markets
  • Tech & Biz
  • Countries
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
The Exchange
LOGIN
A session at the ICJ. The Court has ruled in favour of Somalia by defining the boundary using a 1934 treaty agreement between Italy and Britain. www.theexchange.africa

A session at the ICJ. The Court has ruled in favour of Somalia by defining the boundary using a 1934 treaty agreement between Italy and Britain. [Photo/ICJ]

Which way for Kenya and Somalia after ICJ ruling?

Kenya and Somalia have been in a feud for years over the contested stretch of the Indian Ocean believed to have enormous deposits of oil and gas.

by Njenga Hakeenah
October 12, 2021
in Business, Countries
0
Share on FacebookShare on LinkedIn
  • The ICJ has split the disputed maritime triangle between Kenya and Somalia
  • ICJ rejected Kenya’s argument of a pre-existing agreement with Somalia on a parallel boundary
  • The court also rejected Somalia’s claims that Kenya violated international laws

The International Court of Justice (ICJ) has ruled in favour of Somalia by defining the boundary using a 1934 treaty agreement between Italy and Britain.

By so doing, the colonial powers beacons have been recognised pursuant to international law and conventions.

However, the ruling remains a grey area since on March 18, 2021, Kenya announced that it would not participate in the Maritime Delimitation Case at the ICJ.

This decision, according to Kenya’s Foreign Affairs Ministry, was on account of procedural unfairness at the Court. The decision, the MFA said, was made after deep reflection and extensive consultation on how best to protect the sovereignty and territorial integrity of the Republic of Kenya.

In addition to other reasons why Kenya would not be a participant, the MFA said that the Kenyan government had also informed the Court that influential third party commercial interests were fuelling the case that threatened to destabilize the peace and security of an already fragile region.

Read: Sleeping giant awakening in Somalia banking sector?

“The speed at which the matter was rushed before the Court and the players involved in this dispute, pointed to a well-orchestrated strategy of pitting the countries against each other in total disregard to the precarious security situation in the region. Influential third parties are intent on using instability in Somalia to advance predatory commercial interests with little regard to peace and security in the region,” noted the MFA.

On October 12, 2021, the ICJ has ruled in favour of Somalia in the case pitting the two countries against each other.

Kenya and Somalia have been in a feud for years over the contested stretch of the Indian Ocean believed to have enormous deposits of oil and gas. Both countries claim ownership of the strip.

To push the ICJ to extend the case hearing period, Kenya attributed the request to the Covid-19 pandemic saying it struck when the East African nation had just recruited a new legal team.

Kenya argued that its legal team had not had an opportunity to have preparatory meetings and engagements regarding the case. The court has failed to appreciate the fact that Kenya is exactly where it was at the beginning of 2020 with regards to its compilation of its international legal team.

“Without such necessary preparations, Kenya is of the considered view that any participation in the hearing will be nothing more than a perfunctory, cosmetic and symbolic exercise,” noted the MFA statement.

Kenya said that the seriousness of the case required proper and adequate preparation and thus, it would be ill-advised for the country to participate in a complex case with far-reaching consequences with inadequate preparation.

With these outstanding issues and other related matters, Kenya said it was forced Kenya to stand back from the court insisting that the resolution of the border dispute was rightful on the bilateral and or continental platform.

Top UN court to rule on bitter Kenya-Somalia border spat - France 24
The disputed zone between Kenya and Somalia. [Photo/ France 24]
Why the Kenya-Somalia border dispute?

The disagreement between the two countries comes from a dispute over the direction their border extends into the Indian Ocean. Somalia, a horn of Africa nation, argues that its maritime boundary should be in the same path as the country’s land border. In essence, the border should run in the same south-easterly direction.

However, Kenya says the border should take a 45-degree turn at the shoreline running latitudinally. This leaves Kenya with a larger share of the maritime area.

In addition to its oil and gas, the disputed area which is estimated at 100,000 square kilometres is also a rich ground for fishing.

With these riches, both countries accuse each other of auctioning off blocks in the area.

Read: Kenya, Ethiopia pulling together as Somalia wavers

The deteriorating relationship is a matter of concern since the dispute could spark an armed confrontation between the two countries.

The biggest underlying issue is the oil, gas and tuna rich maritime territory ownership in the Indian Ocean and the question that now begs an answer is whether these African neighbours can afford an armed confrontation.

Casualties of the Kenya-Somalia border dispute

In February 2019, Kenya expelled Somalia’s ambassador and recalled its ambassador from Mogadishu claiming that Somalia had auctioned oil blocs in the disputed territory. In tandem, Kenya introduced a compulsory stopover in Wajir for planes from Mogadishu. Kenya also pooled its troops from the interior of Somalia towards their shared border an action that left Somalia vulnerable to al-Shabaab attacks.

Trade between the two countries has also suffered from the March 2020 Somalia ban of the importation of Miraa/khat from Kenya. This followed a decision by Kenya to stop issuing visas on arrival to Somalis.

But there could be a silver lining for traders from both countries since in August 2021, Somalia Prime Minister Mohamed Hussein Rooble assured that cross border trade between Kenya and Somalia would resume soon.

Prior to the announcement, Rooble held a closed-door meeting with Somali traders in Mombasa Wednesday. The meeting called for the strengthening of the diplomatic relationship between the two countries and the continuous collaboration in different sectors of the economy.

In 2019, Kenya exported US$116 million worth of goods to Somalia. The main products that Kenya exported to Somalia, according to the OEC, were rolled tobacco (US$41.2 million), other vegetable products (US$13 million), and Tea (US$5.71 million).

Over the past 22 years, exports of Kenya to Somalia have increased at an annualized rate of 6.02 per cent up from US$31.9 million in 1997 to US$116 million in 2019.

On the other hand, Somalia exported US$4.32 million to Kenya in the same period. The main products that Somalia exported to Kenya were prefabricated buildings (US$3.44 million), other electrical machinery (US$210,000), and other cast iron products (US$210,000).

In the last 22 years, Somalia’s exports to Kenya increased at an annualized rate of 31.4 per cent, from US$10, 500 in 1997 to US$4.32 million in 2019.

Way forward

The Italian Institute for International Political Studies (ISPI) notes that although the two countries’ maritime territorial dispute needed guidance by international maritime laws principles, they should have explored alternative dispute resolution mechanisms before resorting to the ICJ.

“The zero-sum outcomes associated with the ICJ are not desirable in this context, hence the need for Kenya and Somalia to move towards a win-win solution through diplomatic dialogue,” notes ISPI.

ISPI added that the African Union’s Panel of the Wise was capable of leading the parties to the negotiating table since it is not hostile to any of the parties.

The AU panel could have facilitated negotiations so that both parties could have agreed to a joint exploration arrangement for mutual interest guided by a treaty like the Nigeria-Sao Tome and Principe Joint Development Authority. This Authority was created after the two states signed a treaty for a joint exploration venture in the Bight of Bonny.

As it stands now, Kenya and Somalia are set for a lengthy impasse with the ICJ ruling in favour of Somalia.

Read: World Bank gives Somalia US$75mn funding for healthcare

Tags: BritainEast AfricaHorn of AfricaICJInternational Court of JusticeItalyKenyaKenya-Somalia border disputeKhatMaritime disputeMFAMiraaSomalia

STATE OF ECONOMY - GET THE REPORT

ASSESSING EAST AFRICA

Loading...

Njenga Hakeenah

I have 10 years of experience in multimedia journalism and I use the skills I have gained over this time to meet and ensure goal-surpassing editorial performance. Africa is my business and development on the continent is my heartbeat. Do you have a development story that has to be told? Reach me at [email protected] and we can showcase Africa together.

Related Posts

Congo joins the EAC (www.theexchange.africa)
Business

What does it mean for regional trade, investment after DRC became EAC’s 7th Member State?

May 18, 2022
www.theexchange.afrcia
Countries

Eyes on trade: Kenya seeking to deepen bilateral relationship with United Arab Emirates

May 11, 2022
Growth in employment earmarks Kenya's post-pandemic economic recovery. www.theexchange.africa
Countries

Growth in employment earmarks Kenya’s post-pandemic economic recovery

May 11, 2022
Next Post
A research lab. Many African governments don’t spend a significant percentage of their GDP on research. www.theexchange.africa

Scaling African research commercialization by engaging diaspora professionals

The press conference to announce sponsors for this year’s event. Lavine International Agency Chief Executive Officer Diana Laizer (In black) says the event will be continental. www.theexchange.africa

ABSA, PwC, Azam to support Consumer Choice Awards Africa

The X3 G01 in assembly Hall 54 on 6/5/17 - File: 060417GR34

Egyptian automotive aftermarket sees massive growth

Please login to join discussion




This months edition

May Edition

Features

EdTech role in African development
Tech & Business

EdTech’s role in African development

by Kanyali Muthui
May 16, 2022
0

Due to the pandemic, the topic of innovation in education has never been more crucial.  While most developed countries moved...

Read more
investment in African science and technology
Tech & Business

Investing in Africa’s science and technology: Where are we now?

by Kanyali Muthui
May 16, 2022
0

The continent’s digital revolution can largely be driven by building the necessary skills for the short- and long-term future, and...

Read more
Fintech revolution in Africa
Tech & Business

The Fintech Revolution in Africa’s FX Markets

by Kanyali Muthui
May 11, 2022
0

With over 548 million registered mobile money users in sub-Saharan Africa, increased internet access and readily available mobile money solutions,...

Read more
www.theexchange.africa
Countries

US – Nigeria Trade Relations: An Overview

by Wanjiku Njugunah
May 2, 2022
0

Nigeria is currently the United States' 54th largest goods trading partner, with US$7.8 billion in total goods trade as of...

Read more
A previous conference for African Insurtech sector. The Insurtech boom is deepening insurance uptake in Africa. www.theexchange.africa
Tech & Business

Insurtech boom deepening the uptake of insurance in Africa

by june njoroge
May 2, 2022
0

Kenya-based Pula is another distinguished insurtech making waves in the continent. It provides small scale farmers with agricultural insurance and...

Read more

News

Banking
Industry & Trade
Investing
Money Deals
Regional Markets
Tech & Biz
Opinion

Countries

Kenya
Tanzania
Uganda
Burundi
Rwanda
Southern Africa
Ethiopia

More

My Account
Contact us
Advertise
About us
Help Center

Subscribers Center

E-paper
Premium Stories
Education Rates
Corporate Subscriptions
Weekely Newsletter

  • My account
  • About us
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Refund Policy – The Exchange
  • Sitemap

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Banking
  • Industry & Trade
  • Investing
  • Money Deals
  • Regional Markets
  • Tech & Biz
  • Countries
  • Opinion
  • Login
  • Sign Up
  • Cart

© 2021 The Exchange - Powered by MediapixManaged by Supported by Digihandler,

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In